The Receipt Room
North Miami Arrest Records Update: Third Man Charged in Fake-Police Kidnapping That Ended With a Killing in the Redlands
Vince Cabrera with the newest entry in the North Miami arrest records: a Tampa traffic stop for speeding put Sheldon Diaz, 32, in handcuffs on Miami-Dade warrants — the third arrest in an October abduction by men wearing POLICE shirts, one of them now facing the same seven-felony stack as the first two. All charges are allegations.

Here Are the Receipts
Sources attached — check them yourself
| Document | Third Arrest Made in Fatal Kidnapping of Miami-Dade Man by Men Posing as Police |
| Agency | The Miami Focal — reporting the Miami-Dade Sheriff’s Office and the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office |
| Document date | 2026-11-13 |
| Case / doc no. | Published November 13, 2026, 6:53 p.m.; arrest November 5, 2026, Tampa traffic stop; abduction October 3–4, 2026, North Miami / Redlands |
| Page / section | Full article |
| Original source | https://focalnews.org/miami-fl/local/third-arrest-made-in-fatal-kidnapping-of-miami-dade-man-by-men-posing-as-police |
| Retrieved | 2026-11-15T05:32:00-05:00 |
What Happened
The stop was for speeding. It ended a month-long run.
Hillsborough County deputies pulled over a vehicle shortly before midnight on November 5 near East Fletcher Avenue and USF Palm Drive in Tampa after clocking it at 50 mph in a 35 mph zone with an improper temporary license plate, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office. Inside were Sheldon Diaz, 32, a THC resin pen, $10,000 in cash and multiple cellphones, authorities said — and, on the computer, active warrants out of Miami-Dade County.
Diaz was arrested on a charge of possession of cannabis resin and is being held on the Miami-Dade warrants, which include attempted murder and falsely impersonating a law enforcement officer during a felony resulting in injury or death. He remains in custody in Hillsborough County, and when he will be transferred to South Florida was not clear in the report read. Detectives have not released additional details about his alleged role.
The charges are allegations; Diaz is presumed innocent.
The warrants reach back to the night of October 3, and the Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office account of that night is the darkest kind of only-in-Miami. About 9:41 p. m.
, five men arrived at the Aliro apartment complex at 14040 Biscayne Boulevard in North Miami and waited for a 22-year-old resident to leave his building, investigators said. Shortly after midnight, as he crossed the parking lot, two armed men got out of a gray 2026 Toyota Camry fitted with flashing red and blue lights, wearing baseball caps and long-sleeved black shirts with the word POLICE printed on the back. They ordered him to the ground, handcuffed him, and took his phone and apartment keys, authorities said.
Three of the men used the keys to enter his third-floor apartment, where they encountered another man; gunfire was exchanged inside, and one of the intruders — Devorise Carl Johnson, 21 — was struck multiple times before the three escaped through a third-story bedroom window, investigators said. Johnson was later dropped off at Jackson North Medical Center and was the first suspect arrested. Outside, the remaining men forced the 22-year-old into the Camry and drove him to the area of Southwest 216th Street and Southwest 189th Avenue in the Redlands, where he was shot multiple times and killed, authorities said.
A sheriff's captain found his body by a roadside near plant nurseries about 7:25 a. m. on October 4; an autopsy ruled the death a homicide.
The Dirt does not name him. Investigators say the suspects later set the Camry on fire near Southwest 248th Street and Southwest 157th Avenue.
The second arrest was Naquon Jahrell Fagan, 25, who investigators say rented the Camry in his name from October 2 through October 4 and was captured on surveillance footage allegedly purchasing gloves hours before the crime; cellphone location records also placed him in areas connected to the case, according to his arrest report. Johnson and Fagan each face seven felony charges, including first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, armed kidnapping, armed robbery and impersonating a police officer resulting in death. Diaz is the third man charged.
Anyone with information is asked to contact Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office Detective J. Rodriguez at 305-471-2400, or Miami-Dade Crime Stoppers anonymously at 305-471-8477.
What the Records Show
Verification. The Miami Focal's full report was read on November 15, 2026 (published November 13, 2026). It attributes the November 5 Tampa traffic stop, the cash/phones/pen found in the vehicle, the cannabis-resin charge and the Miami-Dade warrant charges to the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office, and the account of the October 3–4 abduction, the apartment gunfire, the Redlands killing, the autopsy ruling, the burned Camry and the Johnson and Fagan arrests and charges to the Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office and to Fagan's arrest report as reported.
The desk sought a second independent report of the Diaz arrest in this run; the arrest is also the subject of body-camera coverage carried November 13, but the full second report was not read, and that limit is stated here plainly. The story is published on the strength of the two named sheriff's offices whose accounts the Focal report carries. Consistent with the Dirt's standing rule, the deceased victim — an adult whose name authorities have released — is not named here.
Every charge in this story is an allegation; no defendant has been convicted in this case.
What Remains Unconfirmed
- Diaz's alleged specific role in the October 3–4 events has not been detailed by detectives in the report read.
- When Diaz will be transferred from Hillsborough County to Miami-Dade custody was not clear in the report read.
- Whether the remaining members of the five-man group described by investigators have all been identified or charged was not stated in the report read.
- All charges are allegations; all three defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Case Timeline
- 2026-10-03:
- 2026-10-04:
- 2026-11-05:
- 2026-11-13:
- 2026-11-15:
Share This
Email · WhatsApp · Copy link: https://themiamidirt.com/article/north-miami-fake-police-kidnapping-third-arrest-diaz
Related Dirt
- Miami Federal Jury Convicts Florida Pastor in the Assassination of Haiti's President — Fifth Defendant, Life on the Table
- FBI Miami Investigation Ends in 27 Years: Maryland Man Sentenced in Federal Court for Sex Trafficking Two Women Across Six States
- Miami Beach Taxi Driver Arrested After a 9-Year-Old Was Struck on Ocean Drive — the Miami Beach Police Blotter Case, From the Arrest Report
